Obituaries
Elsie L. Nuechterlein, 99
Elsie L. Nuechterlein passed away in her sleep recently at Homestead Village retirement community at the age of 99. She was born in Atwood, Kansas to John and Emma Schiessler. She grew up in Atwood, Kansas and Englewood, Colorado. She graduated from Englewood High School in 1943.
Elsie was married to Melvin H. Nuechterlein in 1946 until his death in 2007. She was predeceased by both her parents and her brother, Marvin and her sister, Elaine.
Elsie was employed as a secretary for 25 years by Millburn New Jersey Public Schools from which she retired in 1990.
Elsie and Mel traveled all over the United States and the world. She enjoyed gardening and reading. After living in New Jersey for over 50 years, Elsie and Mel moved to Homestead Village in Lancaster, Pennsylvania in 2004. They joined Mount Calvary Lutheran Church in Lititz in 2005.
In accordance with Elsie’s wishes, a cremation and interment will take place at Mount Calvary on January 12th, 2026.
Surviving are her three sons: David, Robert and James Nuechterlein; her daughter Jean Larson; and her eight grandchildren: Anne, Ryan, Matthew, and Christopher Nuechterlein, Lauren Louis, Kelly Reece, and Christine and Katherine Larson.
In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions may be made to Mount Calvary Lutheran Church, Lititz, PA or to Homestead Village, Lancaster, PA.
Leave a condolence on this Memorial Page
Condolences to the Family
January 11, 2026
I met Elsie and Mel when they first moved to Lancaster Pa and came into the office at Mt Calvary where I worked. They were both so happy and sweet and we enjoyed talking about New Jersey where I came from. Elsie was always so positive and loving to my 2 daughters over the years we shared our faith at Mt Calvary. Our whole family will miss her but know she is in paradise with our loving Father. Marcia Morehead
January 10, 2026
“Miss Elsie” was always so good to my son and I. She lived close and offered to take us to church if our car wouldn’t start. She made me feel welcome at Sunday School on days I didn’t. Miss Elsie ( as my son called her when he was small ) always had something dear to say to us. I had a note ready to send her when I heard of her passing and I am so, so sorry. Family – know she will be missed.
Nancy W.
January 09, 2026
”Us kids” all have fond memories of our families getting together regularly despite being separated by so many miles. We all now appreciate how much effort Aunt Elsie, Uncle Mel, and our parents went to for this to have been made possible.
Gary Nuechterlein
January 09, 2026
What a gracious woman was Elsie! I admired her so along with her dear Mel. May she rest in peace in the loving arms of our Savior. May God grant you comfort and peace, also, during this time. Nancy M, church member
January 08, 2026
we are sorry for your loss we have lost a very sweet person
michelle and jeff mt calvary
January 06, 2026
I have many fond memories of seeing Aunt Elsie and Uncle Mel and their kids Dave, Bob, Jim, and Jean in Frankenmuth, Michigan, for the Nuechterlein family reunions. We always looked forward to those get togethers and once travelled to New Jersey to visit them at home. Elsie was always so warm and welcoming! She will be missed.
Keith Nuechterlein
January 06, 2026
My thoughts and prayers are with all the family members. I remember special times with Aunt Elsie like going to the special chicken restaurant in Michigan, visiting with her at the farm house in Michigan and many other times for reunions. Aunt Elsie was great at writing notes and cards which were very special to me.
Kaye Nuechterlein
January 06, 2026
I thank God for the love and great memories I have of all my times with Aunt Elsie. She is definitely a faithful child of God. Thinking of her brings huge smiles to me. Thank you, God, for placing her into my life.
Joanne (Nuechterlein) Wheatley
